Catholic priests and bishops must obey the words of Jesus of Nazareth
May 3, 2023 · By Fr. Shay Cullen
Catholic priests and bishops must obey the words of Jesus of Nazareth
Fr. Shay Cullen
28 April 2023
Challenging pedophile priests in court is possible today in the Philippines. Much has changed in the Philippine judiciary in the past twenty years. Prosecutors and judges in the family courts are armed with 37 laws that mandate that they protect children and bring their abusers to swift and strict justice. Many prosecutors and judges are doing just that in Luzon and other parts of the Philippines.
Church influence over government prosecutors and judges has greatly diminished since the previous administration of President Rodrigo Duterte who threatened to expose the alleged wrongdoings of bishops and priests, saying he himself was sexually abused by a priest. The Philippine judiciary is more independent and many women prosecutors and judges (and men, too) in the family courts are strong and independent-minded and will never bend to church pressure.
In February 2019 in Negros Occidental four years have passed and no action taken in the office of the city prosecutor in Cadiz city in the case of a four years old victim of rape allegedly by Father Aron Buenacosa. Despite a non bailable charge of rape he walks free with alleged impunity saying mass and doing his priestly duties. The Secretary of justice should investigate.We can say he is innocent until proven guilty so let the case proceed and there be justice.
There are some strong-minded prosecutors and judges holding priests accused of child abuse accountable and bringing them to court at present. The latest and most shocking investigation into clerical sexual sexual abuse by Catholic priests has been released in a report by Attorney General Anthony Brown in Baltimore in the United States. As many as 156 priests abused more than 600 children over decades.
The victim-/survivors have reported the sexual abuse by priests over years and the archbishop of Baltimore, Bishop William E. Lori, issued a statement of apology after the release of the report last 5 April 5 2023. The report said: “Time and again, members of the Church’s hierarchy resolutely refused to acknowledge allegations of child sexual abuse for as long as possible.” Dioceses have been challenged to call all abusers to repent and submit to the civil law.
In the Philippine church, no similar investigation by an outside agency would ever happen. There is too much to deny and hide as Cardinal Antonio Tagle said on BBC some years ago that child sexual abuse in the church is a private internal matter for the church to deal with. Pope Francis has a different teaching. They must be held accountable to the civil authorities, no impunity is allowed.
In the Philippines, a Catholic priest is facing justice in Cagayan province. Father Israel Karole Ubina is in jail, no bail. He is accused of multiple rape and sexual assault of a 15-year old church volunteer. Father Conrad Mantac, 62, was arrested in Bacolod City in March this year 2023 for the alleged rape of a 17-year old choir member. Sagay City Regional Trial Court Judge Reginald Fuentebella issued the arrest warrant.
In such cases were the child’s testimony is strong and clear, the judge just has to listen and believe. “Let it be clear that before these abominations, the church will spare no effort to do all that is necessary to bring to justice whosoever has committed such crimes,” Pope Francis said. He warned the clergy who abuse children, “Convert and hand yourself over to human justice, and prepare for divine justice.”
We see hope in the Philippine judiciary that is acting on Christian convictions and principles more swiftly and more determined to bring healing through justice for the child victims, hopeful that the clerics and bishops will hand over the pedophile priests to be held accountable and not hide them away in retreat houses and therapy shelters to keep them away from justice in the false hope to cure them. The abusers get the therapy in a comfortable retreat house while the victims are abandoned and intimidated. They get no therapy, no help, no Good Samaritan to heal and help. Their parents are paid off to drop any complaint and bribery abounds. The Philippine law is clear, to molest a child below 16 statutory rape and if one does it they answer to the law. Justice is coming and coming swiftly.
In Iba, Zambales, Judge Maribel F. Mariano-Beltran is holding continuous hearings all day, taking testimony of the child in the morning and cross examination in the afternoon. The child victim is not stressed by the long wait of weeks, even months, before cross-examination. More recently, the prosecutors are petitioning the judges to refer vulnerable children to protective homes where they are healed and empowered. Provincial Prosecutor Emelyn T. Nacin-Catolico has just approved a case of sexual assault and qualified rape and acts of lasciviousness to be elevated to the court against the father of a 15-year old child. Her mother was trying to stop the child testifying and the prosecutors had her protected in the care of the Preda home. The prosecution’s strong case was researched and written by assistant provincial prosecutor Olivia V. Non-Finones in 10 pages of convincing legal arguments.
Preda Foundation social workers support 77 child victims /survivors in a residential therapeutic home. They overcome the trauma of the abuse by releasing their anger, hurt and pain through emotional release therapy and become empowered, self-confident and articulate in testifying about how and when they were abused. The children win an average of 17-18 convictions every year. In 2022 alone, they won 21 convictions. Life sentences were handed down by the judges in most cases.
Until recently, priests believed they could get away with the abuse because of their status, money, prestige and support of the bishop. One protective bishop calls the child abuser priest “his son.” Pope Francis called them otherwise. “Often, behind their boundless amiability, impeccable activity and angelic faces, they shamelessly conceal a vicious wolf ready to devour innocent souls,” he said in his Christmas message in 2018. With such “vicious wolf” tendencies lurking behind a mask of sanctity and an image of holiness, they rape and abuse their victims and the pedophile priest can persuade everyone that they are innocent, showing “Impeccable activity and angelic faces.” They blame the child for lying and declare that they are innocent victims themselves.
Clearly, some clerics and bishops are covering up crimes. This is what brings the priesthood and our faith into disrepute. Faith is anchored in Jesus of Nazareth, his words and actions, not so much in dogmas, rites and rituals. Faith is about believing and acting on the belief that goodness, truth, and love of neighbor through social action for justice will overcome evil.
This is the challenge facing every member of the church, the People of God: to be a person of integrity, true faith in standing against evil and loving by helping our neighbor as did the Good Samaritan healing the wounded and the abused.
Jesus of Nazareth said the child is the most important in the Kingdom and the abusers must be brought to justice, “a giant millstone be tied around his neck and he be thrown into the deep sea.” (Matthew 18:7) The pedophile priests and those who protect them abuse the victims again and again by denying them justice and healing. They also damage the faith of the People of God, damage the priesthood, and bring all good honest priests and religious into disrepute.
Most, however, just stay quiet and do little about it. Pope Francis said that some pedophile priests and their backers, “without batting an eye,” were ready to enter into a “web of corruption” by abusing children and covering up the crimes or failing to report such sexual child abuse. Everyone has to stand and support Pope Francis and all the good people that are speaking out and demanding honesty in cleansing the church of the “filth” of clerical child abuse as Pope Benedict said and bring back the fighting spirit for human rights, child rights, justice, dignity and the goodness and truth that will overcome evil. This is what faith is: action for justice and truth. Send any information you may have about any victim of child abuse and you and the victim will get support and help.
